Karl Woodley was named the culprit through careful investigation and the weather clears the next day, allowing the manor guests to leave. However, the professor,
Arthur Conan Doyle finds it unnerving and returns to find that Vicar Jeremy is indeed Sebastian himself. He then proceeds to sit with Ciel for some tea as they explain the real murderer and the motives.
Charles Grey was the one who supposedly murdered Siemens and Sebastian and this was all a ploy to stop Siemens' communication with Germany and frame Woodley because Woodley himself was guilty of a crime he was not detained for. Sebastian reveals to Arthur that he indeed is not human and he leaves the manor in fright. The killing that was not explained, Phelps' killing, was actually because of
Snake. Snake decided to kill Ciel because he thought he was the cause of the
Noah's Ark Circus other
first string members' disappearance, but his snake ended up poisoning Phelps instead. Ciel ends with a lie that he is still searching for the Noah's Ark Circus members and has Snake join his house as a footman. Sebastian shows the servants he is alive by mysteriously "arising from the dead" when he rings his gravestone bell, causing the servants to dig him up and finding he is indeed alive.