As many know there are theories that the Ciel we know is not the 'real' Ciel but the twin of the 'real Ciel', it said that 'Ciel we know' has a older, healthier and happier mirror twin brother. It said that they both were taken from the fire and were both brought by the cult. In some manga panels they can show a happier and healthier boy that looks like Ciel, while we know Ciel was a shy and sickly child. In the manga it show a child looking like Ciel being stabbed in the stomach and therefore summoned Sebastian in his demon, when Sebastian walks up to 'Ciel we know' he was in cage. When Sebastian asked 'Ciel we know' name is waited a while and then looked over to the table were a body lies, then he says 'Ciel Phantomhive'.